Finding out paternity while you’re pregnant can feel urgent — but also scary. If you’ve been researching non-invasive prenatal paternity testing (NIPP), you’ve probably seen accuracy claims like “99.9%.” That sounds reassuring… but it can still leave you with one big question:
Can a non-invasive prenatal paternity test be wrong?
The honest answer is: the technology is extremely accurate when done correctly, but rare mistakes or inconclusive results can happen. This guide explains exactly how, why, and what you can do to protect yourself.
Quick note: This article is educational, not medical advice. For personal medical concerns, talk to your OB-GYN or a genetic counselor.
Short answer — can a prenatal paternity test be wrong?
Yes, it can be wrong in rare situations.
But when testing is done at the right time, using a high-quality lab and proper sample handling, non-invasive prenatal paternity testing is typically over 99.9% accurate.
What most people experience:
-
Clear “included” paternity result at very high probability, or
-
Clear “excluded” result
-
Occasionally: “inconclusive” (meaning not enough fetal DNA or a complicating factor)
So the real question becomes: when do errors or inconclusive results happen, and how do you avoid them?
How non-invasive prenatal paternity testing works (simple explanation)
Non-invasive prenatal paternity testing uses a blood sample from the mother and a cheek swab from the alleged father.
Here’s what’s happening scientifically:
- During pregnancy, tiny fragments of the baby’s DNA circulate in the mother’s bloodstream. This is called cell-free fetal DNA (cffDNA).
- A lab extracts and separates those fetal DNA fragments from the mother’s DNA.
- The baby’s DNA profile is compared to the alleged father’s DNA.
- The lab calculates the probability of paternity.
Because it only requires a blood draw from the mother, it does not touch the baby or placenta, so it’s considered safe compared to invasive procedures like amniocentesis or CVS.
Reasons a non-invasive prenatal paternity test can be wrong or inconclusive
Even though the science is strong, results can be affected by timing, pregnancy factors, relationship genetics, or lab quality.
1) Testing too early (low fetal DNA fraction)
Most providers require a minimum 7–8 weeks of pregnancy, because earlier than that there may not be enough fetal DNA in the blood.
If the fetal DNA fraction is too low, a test may come back:
-
inconclusive, or
-
(rarely) inaccurate if a low-quality lab pushes results through instead of retesting.
What to do:
Test at 7+ weeks, and use a provider that retests for low fetal DNA when needed.
2) Twins, vanishing twin, or multiple babies
Many NIPP tests cannot reliably separate DNA from twins, so accuracy can drop or testing may be unavailable.
A “vanishing twin” early in pregnancy can also leave extra DNA fragments in the bloodstream, complicating analysis.
What to do:
Always tell your provider if you’ve been told you might be carrying multiples or had early twin indicators.
3) Possible fathers are close relatives
If two potential fathers are brothers, father/son, or close cousins, their DNA can look extremely similar. That can reduce certainty or require extra testing.
What to do:
Tell the lab if the possible fathers are related. A good lab can advise whether extra samples are needed.
4) Sample collection or handling problems
Errors can happen if:
-
samples are mislabeled
-
chain-of-custody is weak
-
collection is done unprofessionally
-
samples are contaminated
This is why some providers require certified collectors or mobile phlebotomy rather than DIY blood draws.
What to do:
Use a provider that controls collection and documents identity properly.
5) Lab quality issues (the biggest avoidable risk)
Recent lawsuits and media coverage have raised concerns about prenatal DNA tests being mishandled or reported incorrectly by low-quality labs.
High-quality labs reduce risk by:
-
using validated SNP technology
-
repeating analysis when results are borderline
-
operating under strict accreditation standards.
What to do:
Choose a provider that works with AABB-accredited labs and publicly lists their lab standards.
What “99.9% accurate” actually means
You’ll often see accuracy expressed as:
-
Probability of paternity: usually 99.9%+ when paternity is confirmed
-
Exclusion: 0% when paternity is ruled out
This doesn’t mean the test “guesses.” It means the lab compares thousands of DNA markers, and the statistics become overwhelmingly clear.
A helpful way to think about it:
-
A high-quality NIPP test is like matching thousands of puzzle pieces between baby and alleged father.
-
If they fit, the probability becomes extremely strong.
-
If they don’t, paternity is excluded.
How to reduce your risk of a wrong result (checklist)
Here’s a practical list you can follow.
Choose a provider using AABB-accredited labs
AABB accreditation is one of the most recognized standards for relationship DNA testing.
Internal link suggestion:
Link “AABB-accredited labs” to your Non-Invasive Prenatal Paternity Test page if you mention accreditation there.
Test at the right time
-
7+ weeks pregnant minimum (many providers list 7–8 weeks).
-
If your pregnancy is earlier, wait until fetal DNA is high enough.
Use professional collection
Avoid cheap providers that encourage sketchy home blood collection.
You already offer professional collection with mobile phlebotomy — that’s a real trust advantage.
Be upfront about special circumstances
Tell your provider if:
-
twins or possible twins
-
IVF / donor sperm
-
prior recent pregnancy loss
-
possible fathers are related
Good labs will adjust the testing plan or tell you if limitations apply.
When should you question a result or get medical guidance?
Most NIPP tests are straightforward. But you should talk to a professional if:
-
the result is inconclusive
-
your pregnancy has multiple-baby complications
-
you’re making major medical or legal decisions based on the result
-
you have a medical condition that affects cell-free DNA testing (rare, but possible)
For non-paternity genetic screening (like NIPT for Down syndrome), mainstream medical sources stress that screening results sometimes need confirmation with diagnostic testing.
FAQs people ask about prenatal paternity test accuracy
Can previous pregnancies affect my results?
Usually no. Cell-free fetal DNA clears from the bloodstream after pregnancy. If you recently had a pregnancy loss, mention it to your provider just in case.
Can a non-invasive prenatal paternity test be wrong if I’m pregnant with twins?
Twins are a known limitation for many labs. Some won’t test; others may require special methods.
What if both possible fathers are brothers?
This situation may reduce certainty because close relatives share lots of DNA. A high-quality lab can advise next steps.
Is an at-home prenatal paternity test accurate?
Cheek swabs at home are fine if collected correctly, but maternal blood should be drawn professionally and linked properly to identity to avoid mix-ups.
Is non-invasive prenatal paternity testing safer than amniocentesis?
Yes. Non-invasive testing is just a blood draw, while amnio/CVS involve needles into the uterus or placenta and carry miscarriage risk.
Bottom line
A non-invasive prenatal paternity test is one of the most accurate and safest ways to determine paternity during pregnancy — when done under the right conditions.
Errors are rare, but they’re more likely when:
-
testing is done too early
-
twins are involved
-
possible fathers are close relatives
-
samples are mishandled
-
labs are unaccredited or low quality
If you’re pregnant and want answers you can feel confident about, we help make the process simple and private.
We work only with AABB-accredited labs, and testing can be done as early as 7 weeks with certified collection.
Contact us to schedule your prenatal paternity test or ask any questions.